Many Asian Americans are questioning the state of mental health in their community after the shootings in Monterey Park and Half Moon Bay.
According to Jenny Wang, Ph.D, who is a therapist and author of “Permission to Come Home: Reclaiming Mental Health as Asian Americans,” therapy can help with anger management, conflict resolution and negotiation skills. “Does therapy prevent all violence? Probably not,” she said. But therapy provides skills and support that may reduce it.
Wang said violence happens when people cannot regulate their internal emotions. She said that many AAPI immigrants become emotionally unavailable and repress certain feelings to adapt to the challenges that their new life brings.
“This value of emotional stoicism – this idea that when we have emotional upheaval or upset, we try as much as we can to withhold emotional dysregulation – they see it as a strength,” Wang said.
Roots In The Past
Before navigating domestic life in the United States, AAPI immigrants often navigated difficult lives in their motherlands, fraught with war and poverty. And, according to Wang, wallowing the bitterness brought by those experiences becomes a value.
Many Chinese fled famine and political repression. Vietnamese and Koreans suffered years of war. Filipinos escaped dictatorship. Cambodians ran away from genocide. Many Japanese carried a stiff upper lip when they or their ancestors were put into concentration camps. In all these cases, Asian immigrants have been beset by colonialism, poverty, war or intergenerational trauma, said Wang.
But the appearance of stoicism belies the true reality.
“It’s actually a protective mechanism,” says Esther Lee, a therapist from San Fernando Valley. “It’s kept them safe this long”.
The defense mechanism is an indicator of the lack of coping and communication skills, Lee said. It leads to pent-up resentment, anger, and frustration that boils right below the surface.
“Asian elders display stoicism when faced with inner turmoil, but if it’s left unmanaged,” Wang says, “it sometimes have really harmful consequences.”
Community And Burden
The defense mechanism is also rooted in collectivist attitudes from Asian cultures, said Lee. Since an individual’s worth and identity derive from the community and their families, the elders tend to deprioritize their own mental well-being in favor of the well-being of others.
However, as they age, they sometimes cannot give to the community as they once did. Without being able to give to the community, AAPI elders might feel their worth is limited. So as not to be a burden, they isolate themselves.
“They are a very vulnerable population, they’re often really isolated and alone. Not all of them have family nearby that are checking on them,” said Sharon Kwon, a therapist in Los Angeles who has worked with the elderly community in Koreatown.
Kwon said the problem worsens due to shame, plus the idea among meny in the community that therapy is for only for “crazy people.” And machismo might be another playing factor.
“I also think that Asian American cultures are inherently very patriarchal and collective, which often creates the perfect recipe for domestic violence in the home,” said Kwon.
Hope In Present And Future
According to Wang, the younger generations might put a stop to the cycle of closed emotions, loneliness and despair.
“I’m a firm believer that when the younger generation – people in their 20s, 30s, and 40s – actually pursue mental health and well-being, that is the catalyst to perhaps the older generation [seeking for help]”, says Wang.
For her, therapy is more than just speaking about feelings: it’s about arming our loved ones with the tools to navigate their homes, workplaces and all the spaces in between. Sharing your own experiences with therapy is key.
Starting Simple
To introduce elders to therapy, Wang suggests telling them about how you went to a therapist for a problem, like with work or school. Then list the ways a therapist has helped.
“One of the things that Asian elders worry about is that you kind of sit there and vent about your problems, but nothing changes,” said Wang.
But Wang said it is not just venting. “It’s actually about developing a plan to change things in our lives for the better, or to learn a skill, like communication, or like learning how to negotiate.”
Kwon added that therapists can help elders process difficult emotions, like loneliness, guilt, and feeling like a burden. “We can also even link them to case management services that actually help you with more day to day stuff,” says Kwon.
Kwon belongs to the “Yellow Chair Collective” – a group of Asian American therapists. According to their website, Asian American therapists can help elders by knowing the ins-and-outs of a culture, and being open minded and curious about their viewpoints.
Asian American therapists take the onus to be sensitive to cultural barriers, says April Tith, a therapist from Long Beach. “Cultural humility is incorporated into their practice. “Searching for clinicians that prioritize cultural sensitivity and inclusion can make [finding a therapist] more successful and trusting,” Tith said.
Professional therapy isn’t always accessible, nor always right for every person, Kwon said. In those cases, she suggested churches and temples as great alternatives because they provide community and support. “Churches and pastors were the original therapists,” said Kwon.
“What I love about therapy is that it helps create a sense of personal liberation,” said Lee. “Collective liberation can only happen if personal liberation and peace is being met.”
Additional resources
All elders are eligible for medicare, and can access the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health website. There, they can find mental health providers in their local community.
The Yellow Chair collective is another resource with Asian therapists who are culturally sensitive, and they offer a non-profit service called ENTWINE which offers low-cost mental health services and case management.
What questions do you have about Southern California?
